Gunpowder The American Civil War

The Battle of Gettysburg, 1863

The record
Battle Gettysburg
Date 3 July 1863, the third day
War The American Civil War
Location The open ground before Cemetery Ridge, at the Angle, near Gettysburg, Pennsylvania
Belligerents The Union Army of the Potomac vs the Confederate Army of Northern Virginia
Commanders George G. Meade, with Winfield Scott Hancock holding the ridge (Union) vs Robert E. Lee, the assault under James Longstreet, with George Pickett and Lewis Armistead † (Confederate)
Strength About 12,000 Confederates stepped off across roughly three quarters of a mile of open ground, against a Union line posted behind a stone wall on the ridge with artillery on both flanks
Outcome The assault reached the wall at one point and was destroyed there: the high-water mark of the Confederacy, and the end of the invasion of the North
Union losses About 1,500 in the repulse of the assault
Confederate losses About 6,500, including at least 1,123 killed. Of 11,484 men in the three main commands, 4,802 were lost, 42 in every hundred. Armistead's brigade alone lost 1,057

The Account

Behind the Song

The Song

Listen onSpotifyApple MusicThe Gunpowder Chronicles

Why Armistead’s Charge, and not Pickett’s

The title is a deliberate correction, and it needs explaining because it looks like an error.

The attack is universally called Pickett’s Charge. Pickett commanded one of the three divisions in it and famously survived it, and the name stuck to him. Armistead commanded a brigade inside Pickett’s division, walked in front of it with his hat on his sword, went over the wall at the Angle and died there.

Naming the song after Armistead moves it one rung down the ladder, and the song then moves down one more rung and does not follow Armistead either. It follows “one private stands near Armistead”, and it stays with him for the whole track. Armistead is scenery. The private is the subject. That is the record’s method in one design decision.

The song, against the history

Verse 1 is the wait, and “the heat lies heavy on the field, the midday burns the air” is placing the song in the hours before the walk, not at the walk. This is right: the attack stepped off in the afternoon of a hot 3 July after a two-hour artillery duel, and the waiting is what the men remembered.

The chorus is the record’s only sustained use of her as a protective presence. “I guard your soul as the cannons tear the sky apart, you’re not alone” is a promise about company rather than about survival, which is the distinction this project runs on. She is not offering to keep him alive. She says she will be there, and she is.

Verse 2 puts the terrain in. “The fence ahead stands stark beside the ditch” is the Emmitsburg Road, and it is the single most lethal feature of the field. The road ran across the line of advance with post-and-rail fencing on both sides, and the attacking brigades had to stop under artillery fire and climb it. The killing at that fence is what turned an assault into a catastrophe.

Verse 3 is the collapse of the flanks in the order it happened. “The volleys break the columns to your left” and “the right is shattered, scattered in the smoke” is accurate to the shape: both flanks were taken in enfilade and destroyed, and the survivors converged inward. “But Armistead’s men surge against the storm, you press the wall” is the wedge that reached the Angle.

The final bridge does the history and the thesis at once. “For Armistead lies still beneath the sky, and you beside him breathe your final cry” is the literal outcome at the wall: Armistead fell mortally wounded beside a captured Union gun, and the roughly 250 men who crossed with him were killed, wounded or captured almost to the man.

The song stays inside the private’s eyeline to the last line, and that is why Armistead is lying still beneath the sky rather than being carried off. He was mortally wounded rather than killed outright and lived two days in Union hands, but no man dying at the Angle knew that. What the song gives you is what was visible from the ground at that moment, which is the only vantage it has used since the first verse.

“I know their names”, in the middle bridge, is doing quiet work against the whole apparatus of Gettysburg: a battlefield with more monuments on it than almost any other in the world, where about 250 men crossed that wall and one of them has a statue.

Lyrics

[Verse 1] The heat lies heavy on the field The midday burns the air I watch the ranks in silent rows Their hope laid bare One private stands near Armistead His breath is sharp and slow I feel his fear like rising smoke Before they go The sunlight shivers red The stillness starts to break For death walks with them on the path they take

[Chorus] Run through the fire Into the roar I guard your soul as the cannons tear the sky apart You’re not alone

[Verse 2] The cannon thunder shakes the open ground Yet still you march The smoke drifts thick and blinds the forward line Through heat and starch The shells erupt like storms along the ridge Your steps stay true The fence ahead stands stark beside the ditch I walk with you

[Verse 3] The volleys break the columns to your left They fall and fade The right is shattered, scattered in the smoke Their courage frayed But Armistead’s men surge against the storm You press the wall Through fire and ruin, still you drive ahead Though others fall

[Bridge] I see the tide of battle twist and break The living grasp at hope the guns will take I know their names

[Final Chorus] The thunder falters The daylight dims You stand beside the fallen where your courage burned so bright I stay with you You’re not alone

[Final Bridge] Through drifting smoke I gather those who fell I hear the fading echoes of their last farewell I hold their pain A pale horizon opens past the veil I guide the weary where no shadows trail I lead them on For Armistead lies still beneath the sky And you beside him breathe your final cry I carry you home

Part of Gunpowder The Gunpowder Chronicles All battles, in order