The Great War The First World War, in the Battle of the Frontiers on the Western Front
The Battle of Mons, 1914
| Battle | Mons |
|---|---|
| Date | Sunday 23 August 1914 |
| War | The First World War, in the Battle of the Frontiers on the Western Front |
| Location | The Mons-Condé canal around Mons, in the province of Hainaut, Belgium |
| Belligerents | The British Expeditionary Force vs the German First Army |
| Commanders | Field Marshal Sir John French, with General Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien's II Corps doing most of the fighting, vs Generaloberst Alexander von Kluck |
| Strength | Some 75,000 British in the field, of whom perhaps 35,000 were engaged, against a German First Army usually put at about 150,000; Terence Zuber argues the odds on the day were much closer |
| Outcome | The canal held for a day, and that night the retreat from Mons began |
| British losses | Just over 1,600 killed, wounded and missing, nearly half of them from the 4th Middlesex and the 2nd Royal Irish Regiment |
| German losses | Disputed. British official figures put them above 5,000; Zuber, working from German records, argues they were far lower |
The Account
On Sunday the twenty-third of August 1914 the British army lay along a canal in Belgium and waited for the Germans. The canal runs west from Mons toward Condé, flat and straight, with slag heaps from the coal pits behind it and a bridge every mile or so. The Expeditionary Force had marched up to it the day before and dug in on the southern bank. Most of the men had been in France for less than a fortnight.
They were regulars, and a good many of them were reservists who had been working in civilian jobs a month earlier and had been called back to the colours. Plenty had served in India or South Africa or Egypt. What they shared was the rifle. The British army trained its infantry to put fifteen aimed rounds a minute into a target at three hundred yards, and they had practised it until the bolt worked without any thought at all.
I had already been to that canal. On the Friday a cyclist of the 4th Middlesex named John Parr rode out from Obourg to look for the enemy and found them. He is generally counted as the first British soldier killed in the war. His headstone gives his age as twenty. He was about seventeen, and the stone repeats the lie he told to enlist.
On the Saturday a corporal of the 4th Dragoon Guards fired the first British shot of the war, north of the town. On the Sunday, at about nine in the morning, the German guns opened on the loop the canal makes north of Mons, and the infantry came on behind them.
The loop was the worst place to be. The line bent round Obourg and Nimy there and could be shot into from three sides, and the 4th Middlesex at Obourg and the 4th Royal Fusiliers at the railway bridge at Nimy took the first of it. At Nimy a lieutenant named Maurice Dease kept the battalion’s two machine guns firing as their crews went down, and was hit five times, and died at the dressing station. A private named Sidney Godley held the bridge with one of the guns while the battalion pulled back. When it was over he took the gun apart, threw the pieces in the canal and was taken prisoner. Those were the first two Victoria Crosses of the war.
The Germans paid for the canal. How much is still argued, and the British figures are higher than the German ones. The rifles did what they had been trained to do, and it did not change the arithmetic. By the afternoon battalions were being drawn back from the bends. At dusk the German buglers sounded the cease fire along their line. That night word came that the French army on the right was falling back, and the British went south with it.
They walked for about two weeks and two hundred miles, in August heat, as far as the Marne. Then they turned and went north again, to a Flemish town called Ypres, and by Christmas most of the army that had held the canal had been killed, wounded or captured. The men who replaced them made a different army for a different war, and that war went on for four more years.
The ones I took at Mons were killed by a rifle or a shell on a summer Sunday, holding the place they had been told to hold. A great many of the men who walked away from it ended worse, in gas or in the Flanders mud, and tens of thousands of them were never found at all.
John Parr is buried at St Symphorien, a few miles east of the town. A few yards from him lies George Ellison of the 5th Royal Irish Lancers, killed near Mons at half past nine on the morning of the eleventh of November 1918, ninety minutes before the guns stopped. He had been at Mons in 1914 as well. The first of them and the last of them face each other across the grass. I have both their names.
Behind the Song
The Song
Listen onSpotifyApple MusicThe Great War Chronicles
Why follow?
Spotify no longer recommends music it identifies as made with AI, unless the listener follows the artist. Lady Death is performed by AI, so a follow is the only way new records will reach you there: in Release Radar, in your recommendations, and on release day. Playing a song helps. Following helps far more.
Why Mons
Mons was the first battle the British army fought in the Great War, and it was the last day that army fought the war it had trained for. The working note for this track puts it in one line: Mons is the old world dying in the August light. The British regular was a professional built for colonial campaigns, where skill with a rifle decided things. Mons was where he met industrial war, which has no interest in how well anyone shoots.
That is why the track sounds the way it does. It is the most traditional and disciplined song on the record, with military snare, regal brass and a clean, ceremonial mix. Where the Somme grinds and Cambrai suffocates, Mons stands at attention. The old world had a score, and this is it.
The song follows one unnamed rifleman from his arrival at the canal to his death, and the bridge then turns to everyone who survived him.
The song, against the history
Verse 1 establishes the man and the place. “He’d served from Egypt to the Cape and back” makes him a long-service regular, which is what the 1914 army was, with men who had soldiered across the Empire and in South Africa. “And took his place along the canal floor” is the Mons-Condé canal, which the BEF held along its southern bank. “A Sunday morning rising clean and fine” is exact: 23 August 1914 was a Sunday, and the German guns opened around nine.
The pre-chorus is her only claim on the scene. “I’d seen the steady and the sure since man first drew a blade” sets this man in a line of disciplined soldiers stretching back through the whole catalog, which is why she can say she found them at that canal and mean the type as well as the men.
Verse 2 is the rifle at work. “He fired and worked the bolt and fired again” is the British musketry standard of fifteen aimed rounds a minute. “The German front rank fell before the column slowed / The second rank came marching through the slain” is the picture the British accounts of Mons give, German infantry coming on in close order into rifle fire. The historian Terence Zuber, working from German regimental records, argues the German tactics were more careful and their losses lower than the British believed. The verse is told from inside the British line, and that is how it looked from there.
The two choruses turn on one couplet each. The first is the old world’s terms: “They’d never faced a war that didn’t bow before the brave / They’d never fought a war that didn’t care how well they aimed.” The second is the new world’s scale: “They’d never fought a war too vast for any man to know / They’d never seen the sky go dark with iron and with smoke.” The hook between them stays fixed, “the old way was dying in the August morning light,” and that line is the whole song.
Verse 3 is the withdrawal. “The order came and he was slow to turn” sits on what actually happened that afternoon, as battalions were drawn back from the canal piecemeal. “And the line moved south, no one circled back” is the retreat from Mons, two hundred miles in about two weeks, in which men who could not keep up were left behind. She finds him where he held all day, and the rifle is still warm.
The bridge is the reveal. “The ones I left walked on through Ypres mud” is the BEF’s next battle, First Ypres in October and November 1914, by the end of which the original force had suffered around ninety thousand casualties. “They choked on gas, they drowned beneath the ground / They died in mud where they were never found” is the war that followed. The Menin Gate at Ypres alone carries more than 54,000 names of men with no known grave. Against that, she calls the men of Mons the lucky ones: “They left the world still standing, still upright.”
The final chorus sings both choruses back to back, the old world’s couplet and then the new world’s, and ends on the hook one last time.
Lyrics
[Verse 1] He’d served from Egypt to the Cape and back A rifleman who’d never missed before He crossed to Belgium with his rifle and his pack And took his place along the canal floor
The morning came in quiet on the line He set his cheek against the rifle’s wood A Sunday morning rising clean and fine He held his post the way he knew he should
[Pre-Chorus] I’d seen the steady and the sure since man first drew a blade I’d walked beside their kind ten thousand years or more And I found them at that Mons canal
[Chorus] They’d never faced a war that didn’t bow before the brave They’d never fought a war that didn’t care how well they aimed They fired true, they stood their ground, But the old way was dying in the August morning light And I took them from a world already gone
[Verse 2] The columns came like shadows down the road He fired and worked the bolt and fired again The German front rank fell before the column slowed The second rank came marching through the slain
The bolt worked clean, the barrel running hot He’d never missed and didn’t miss today But two more rose for every man he’d shot And still the column pressed on through the grey
[Pre-Chorus] I’d seen the steady and the sure since man first drew a blade I’d walked beside their kind ten thousand years or more And I found them at that Mons canal
[Chorus] They’d never fought a war too vast for any man to know They’d never seen the sky go dark with iron and with smoke They fired true, they stood their ground, But the old way was dying in the August morning light And I took them from a world already gone
[Verse 3] The order came and he was slow to turn A bullet found him reaching for his pack He felt the ground come up, the daylight burn And the line moved south, no one circled back
I found him in the place he’d held all day The rifle still beside him, barrel warm The Sunday morning fading into grey I took him gently, hand upon his arm
[Bridge] The ones I left walked on through Ypres mud And bled for four more years in iron and blood Four years on not a handful still drew breath The ones who walked away found harder deaths
They choked on gas, they drowned beneath the ground They died in mud where they were never found But the ones I took that Sunday in the light They left the world still standing, still upright
[Final Chorus] They’d never faced a war that didn’t bow before the brave They’d never fought a war that didn’t care how well they aimed They fired true, they stood their ground, But the old way was dying in the August morning light And I took them from a world already gone
They’d never fought a war too vast for any man to know They’d never seen the sky go dark with iron and with smoke They fired true, they stood their ground, But the old way was dying in the August morning light And I took them from a world already gone
And I took them from a world already gone
Part of The Great War The Great War Chronicles All battles, in order