The Great War The First World War, on the Western Front

The Battle of Verdun, 1916

The record
Battle Verdun
Date 21 February to 18 December 1916
War The First World War, on the Western Front
Location The hills, woods and forts around Verdun, on both banks of the Meuse, in north-eastern France
Belligerents France vs the German Empire
Commanders Joseph Joffre, with Philippe Pétain and then Robert Nivelle commanding at Verdun, vs Erich von Falkenhayn, with Crown Prince Wilhelm's Fifth Army
Strength The Germans opened with about 150,000 infantry and nearly 1,200 guns against some 25,000 French on the right bank. By the end, most of the French army had passed through Verdun
Outcome A French defensive victory. The German offensive failed, and by December the line stood close to where it had begun
French losses About 163,000 dead and 216,000 wounded by the count of the Mémorial de Verdun. Other estimates put total French casualties near 400,000
German losses About 143,000 dead and 190,000 wounded by the same count, with other estimates near 350,000. Together, some 300,000 dead

The Account

Behind the Song

The Song

Listen onSpotifyApple MusicThe Great War Chronicles

Why Verdun

Verdun is the flagship of The Great War Chronicles, the song the whole record is built around. It is the longest battle of the war, the one France measures every other by, and the place where the phrase “they shall not pass” came from.

The working brief for it was an absolute booming chorus, equal parts tragic and heroic, close to a memorial song without quite being one. The seed was one line: a mountain of the dead piled up near Verdun. That became the chorus, and the mountain is real. It is the ossuary of Douaumont.

Two choices shape everything. First, Lady Death is kept out of the verses and the chorus entirely. She arrives only in the bridge, and her arrival is the weapon. Second, the song is told from now. The pre-chorus stands in the forest that grew over the battlefield, and the chorus looks at what remains of it: the ossuary and the road.

The song, against the history

Verse 1 is the opening of the battle, in rhymed couplets where every line is a complete statement. “The German guns began to shell, / and every tree for miles fell” is the bombardment of 21 February that destroyed the woods north of the town, where Driant’s chasseurs held the Bois des Caures. “The fort stood empty, half forgot. / A sergeant took it, not a shot” is Fort Douaumont, stripped of its guns and most of its garrison the year before, and taken on 25 February by Sergeant Kunze without a fight. “Four trucks a minute shook the ground” is the Sacred Way, where a lorry passed every fourteen seconds. “They ground the men up like a mill” is the image Verdun has carried ever since, of a machine that took in whole divisions and sent back what was left.

The pre-chorus is the place now. “The forest grew where the guns had stood, / the craters sleep beneath the wood, / the street signs name the empty lanes” is the battlefield today, planted with pine over the shell holes, and the destroyed villages where signboards still name streets that have no houses on them. Its last word, “remains,” means both what is left and the dead.

The chorus comes in two stanzas. The first is the war: “There is a mountain of the dead above Verdun, / there is a road that brought the living to the war.” The mountain is the ossuary, and the road is the Sacred Way. Then three short lines climb one above the other, “and the mountain grew, / and the road went on, / and the names were lost,” before the payoff, “A hundred thousand lie up there unknown.” The ossuary holds the remains of at least 130,000 men who were never identified.

The second stanza is the ossuary itself, and every noun in it is literal. “There is a tower where a lantern burns till dawn” is the forty-six-metre tower and the lantern of the dead that turns at its top. “There is a Sacred Way where wheels ran night and day” is the road again, as it was in 1916. “The enemies rest side by side below” is the vault, where French and German bones lie together because nobody could tell them apart.

Verse 2 is the long middle of the battle. “The hill called Dead Man earned its name, / and the next hill did just the same” is Le Mort-Homme and Hill 304 beside it, fought over from March to May. “The men came back down old and gray” is the rotation Pétain ran, sending divisions up the road and bringing them back before they were destroyed. “A second fort’s last pigeon flew” is Fort Vaux, where Major Raynal sent his last carrier pigeon on 4 June before the fort surrendered for lack of water. “Some sixteen times one village burned” is Fleury, which changed hands sixteen times between June and August.

The bridge is where she arrives. “They shall not pass, the order said” is said once in the whole song, and left without a name on it. The words were General Nivelle’s, in his order of the day of 23 June 1916, though they are popularly credited to Pétain. Then she speaks for the first time: “I watched the trucks go up the line, / and each load carried some of mine. / I laid both armies down in rows, / and that is how a mountain grows.” Everything in the song has been building to that line, and she is the one who says it.

The outro is a second text set to the bridge’s melody, in third person and back in the present. “Each spring the ground gives up a shell, / and now and then a man as well” is still true. The fields around Verdun yield unexploded shells every year, and the ossuary still receives remains. “No one can say which coat he wore” is why the ossuary exists at all. The song ends on its last word, “alone,” held and fading: “and no one up there lies alone.”

Lyrics

[Verse 1] The German guns began to shell, and every tree for miles fell. The fort stood empty, half forgot. A sergeant took it, not a shot. For four days straight the men fell back, and left the fallen on the track. Four trucks a minute shook the ground, and carried back what could be found. The guns stood fast upon the hill, they ground the men up like a mill.

[Pre-Chorus] The forest grew where the guns had stood, the craters sleep beneath the wood, the street signs name the empty lanes, and this is all that still remains:

[Chorus] There is a mountain of the dead above Verdun, there is a road that brought the living to the war, and the mountain grew, and the road went on, and the names were lost. A hundred thousand lie up there unknown.

[Verse 2] The hill called Dead Man earned its name, and the next hill did just the same. The men came back down old and gray; the boys on the trucks looked away. A second fort’s last pigeon flew, and after that no word came through. That summer, when the ground had dried, the soldiers drank where men had died. Some sixteen times one village burned, and sixteen times the French returned.

[Pre-Chorus] The forest grew where the guns had stood, the craters sleep beneath the wood, the street signs name the empty lanes, and this is all that still remains:

[Chorus] There is a tower where a lantern burns till dawn, there is a Sacred Way where wheels ran night and day, and the lantern turns, and the wheels are gone, and the years go by. The enemies rest side by side below.

[Bridge] They shall not pass, the order said, and so the French held on and bled. I watched the trucks go up the line, and each load carried some of mine. I laid both armies down in rows, and that is how a mountain grows:

[Final Chorus] There is a mountain of the dead above Verdun, there is a road that brought the living to the war, and the mountain grew, and the road went on, and the names were lost. A hundred thousand lie up there unknown.

There is a tower where a lantern burns till dawn, there is a Sacred Way where wheels ran night and day, and the lantern turns, and the wheels are gone, and the years go by. The enemies rest side by side below.

[Outro] Each spring the ground gives up a shell, and now and then a man as well. No one can say which coat he wore, and no one asks him anymore. The hill is made of bone and stone, and no one up there lies alone.

Part of The Great War The Great War Chronicles All battles, in order