The Great War The First World War, on the Eastern Front
The Brusilov Offensive, 1916
| Battle | The Brusilov Offensive |
|---|---|
| Date | 4 June to 20 September 1916 |
| War | The First World War, on the Eastern Front |
| Location | Volhynia, eastern Galicia and Bukovina, from the Pripet Marshes south to the Carpathians, in today's western Ukraine |
| Belligerents | The Russian Empire vs Austria-Hungary and the German Empire |
| Commanders | General Aleksei Brusilov, commanding the Southwestern Front, with Aleksei Kaledin's Eighth Army at Lutsk, vs Franz Conrad von Hötzendorf and Erich von Falkenhayn, with Archduke Joseph Ferdinand's Austro-Hungarian Fourth Army and Alexander von Linsingen's German forces |
| Strength | Over half a million Russians and about 1,700 guns at the start, against Austro-Hungarian forces of roughly half that size. Both sides were heavily reinforced through the summer |
| Outcome | The greatest Russian victory of the war. It broke the Austro-Hungarian army for good, could not be kept going, and decided nothing |
| Russian losses | Somewhere between half a million and a million killed, wounded and captured. Norman Stone gives about 500,000; Timothy Dowling nearly a million |
| Central Powers losses | Around 1.5 million by the larger estimates, including some 350,000 Germans and about 400,000 Austro-Hungarian prisoners. Other counts are lower |
The Account
By the spring of 1916 the Russian army had been at war for nearly two years and had very little to show for it. It had been driven out of Poland the summer before. In March it had attacked the Germans at Lake Naroch, in the thaw, and lost very heavily for almost no ground. When the Tsar’s generals met at headquarters in Mogilev in April to plan the summer, most of them wanted to stay on the defensive.
Aleksei Brusilov did not. He was sixty-two, a cavalryman born in Tiflis, and he had just been given command of the Southwestern Front, facing the Austrians across what is now western Ukraine. The commanders of the two fronts to his north, Evert and Kuropatkin, argued that nothing could be done. Brusilov said his front would attack. He was told he could, and that he should expect no extra men or guns to do it with.
So he worked out how to do it without them. Everyone on both sides of the war knew how an offensive went: a long bombardment in one sector, which told the enemy exactly where you were coming, then a mass of infantry into a gap the enemy had had a week to plug. Brusilov did the opposite. He prepared to attack in many places at once along a front of hundreds of miles, so no single point looked like the real one. His men dug saps forward until they were close to the Austrian wire. They rehearsed. The guns registered quietly on their targets. The reserves were kept close.
On the morning of the fourth of June the guns opened along the whole front, and the bombardments were short by the standards of that war, hours where others had taken days. Then the infantry went in. At Lutsk, Kaledin’s Eighth Army broke the Austro-Hungarian Fourth Army in about two days, and took the town within the week. Further south whole Austrian corps simply came apart, and men surrendered by the tens of thousands.
For a few weeks in June it looked as if Austria-Hungary might fall out of the war.
It did not, for two reasons. The first was that Evert, to the north, was supposed to attack as well, and did not. He delayed for weeks, and when he finally went forward in July at Baranovichi it was a failure. The second was the Germans. They moved division after division east to hold their ally up, and by the second half of June German counterattacks had stopped the advance west of Lutsk. Brusilov kept attacking through July and August into ground that got harder every week, until his armies were worn out along the river Stokhod, and in September it was over.
He had saved a great deal for other people. The Germans had to send men east from Verdun. Romania, watching Austria collapse, came into the war in August. The Austro-Hungarian army never fought again as a force that could stand on its own.
He had also lost the Russian army somewhere between half a million and a million men, killed, wounded and captured, and the army that remained did not trust its officers or the Tsar any longer. In March 1917 the Tsar abdicated. That summer the army attacked one last time, failed, and melted away, and the Austrians and Germans walked back into Galicia. In March 1918, at Brest-Litovsk, Russia’s new government signed away more land than Brusilov had ever taken.
Brusilov lived on. He served the Soviet state in his old age and died in Moscow in 1926.
I have no quarrel with him. He was the one general that summer who knew how to win, and he won, and it cost what losing would have cost. The men he spent are in my keeping alongside the ones who were spent for nothing, and I have never been able to tell the two apart.
Behind the Song
The Song
Listen onSpotifyApple MusicThe Great War Chronicles
Why follow?
Spotify no longer recommends music it identifies as made with AI, unless the listener follows the artist. Lady Death is performed by AI, so a follow is the only way new records will reach you there: in Release Radar, in your recommendations, and on release day. Playing a song helps. Following helps far more.
Why the Brusilov Offensive
By the ground it took, it was the most successful Allied offensive of the Great War, carried out by the only Russian general who believed it could be done, and almost nobody in the English-speaking world has heard of it. That is the first reason for the song.
The second is the shape. Every other song on this record knows it is a tragedy from the first note. This one sounds like winning. Brass fanfares, soaring strings, choir swells, a march. The music never stops celebrating, and only the words tell you that everyone dies. It is a victory march that slowly turns into a death sentence, which is exactly what the offensive was for the country that won it.
The song, against the history
Verse 1 is the deadlock, and the man. “The generals met and every one refused / The front was done the east was left for dead / One man alone stood up and volunteered” is the conference at Mogilev in April 1916, where Evert and Kuropatkin argued against attacking and Brusilov alone pressed to go forward.
The pre-chorus is her foreknowledge, quiet and building: “I already knew them all by name / Before the first of them was gone.” It is the breath held before the chorus goes off.
The chorus is built on one anchor, “March through Galicia,” sung between every line. In the first chorus it sounds like a victory march. By the last, the same three words are an invitation from her. The lines between the anchors telescope through time: “One dawn,” “One summer,” “One winter,” and then “One shadow walking without sound who came to take them all.” Each one is bigger than the last, and she is the only thing in the chorus still in the present tense.
“One summer stopped the empire’s heart, and Russia stumbled on” is careful about which empire it means. The summer of 1916 broke Austria-Hungary, and Russia, the winner, kept marching after the fatal blow had landed. “One winter and their house came down” is the revolution of the following winter, and the fall of the Romanovs.
Verse 2 is the breakthrough. “At dawn in June the guns began to speak / By noon the wire and the trenches all were gone / By dusk the Austrian front had split in two” compresses the breaking of the Austro-Hungarian Fourth Army at Lutsk, which took about two days, into one day told in three beats, so the listener feels the speed. “He struck them everywhere and all at once / From Pripet down along the southern peaks” is the method that made it work: attacks across the whole front, from the Pripet Marshes to the Carpathians, so the enemy could not tell where the real blow was.
Verse 3 is the stall. “He called for Evert’s men to join the push” is the support that never came in time from the front to the north. “The Germans filled the holes that he had made” is the reinforcement of the Austrian line by German divisions moved from other fronts, more than twenty of them. “A million men who’d broken through the east / Were breaking slowly now from deep within” is the cost. The army that broke Austria-Hungary was losing its faith in its officers and its Tsar.
The bridge is the aftermath, and the only place a name is sung. The Tsar gone in 1917, the army that won the east dissolving, Galicia back in Austrian hands within the year, and the treaty of Brest-Litovsk in 1918 signing away far more than any of it: “The treaty signed the land away / That Brusilov had bled to win.” Naming him there is what makes the loss personal.
Lyrics
[Verse 1] The east had bled for two long years of war And every yard of ground was dearly paid The dead were lined across the frozen ground And not a single step of progress made
The generals met and every one refused The front was done the east was left for dead One man alone stood up and volunteered To lead the charge that every other fled
[Pre-Chorus] I was there before the order came Standing where the dark meets dawn I already knew them all by name Before the first of them was gone
[Chorus] March through Galicia One dawn that cracked the front apart, and every trench was gone March through Galicia One summer stopped the empire’s heart, and Russia stumbled on March through Galicia One winter and their house came down, and blood ran through the hall March through Galicia One shadow walking without sound who came to take them all March through Galicia
[Verse 2] At dawn in June the guns began to speak By noon the wire and the trenches all were gone By dusk the Austrian front had split in two And Russia thundered ever further on
He struck them everywhere and all at once From Pripet down along the southern peaks A front they’d built and bled across two years Lay shattered and forgotten within weeks
[Pre-Chorus] I was there before the order came Standing where the dark meets dawn I already knew them all by name Before the first of them was gone
[Chorus] March through Galicia One dawn that cracked the front apart, and every trench was gone March through Galicia One summer stopped the empire’s heart, and Russia stumbled on March through Galicia One winter and their house came down, and blood ran through the hall March through Galicia One shadow walking without sound who came to take them all March through Galicia
[Verse 3] He called for Evert’s men to join the push But not a single soldier had been sent The Germans filled the holes that he had made And everything he’d won was finally spent
By autumn all the fury had been gone The army pushed too far and stretched too thin A million men who’d broken through the east Were breaking slowly now from deep within
[Pre-Chorus] I was there before the order came Standing where the dark meets dawn I already knew them all by name Before the first of them was gone
[Chorus] March through Galicia One dawn that cracked the front apart, and every trench was gone March through Galicia One summer stopped the empire’s heart, and Russia stumbled on March through Galicia One winter and their house came down, and blood ran through the hall March through Galicia One shadow walking without sound who came to take them all March through Galicia
[Bridge] The revolution took the throne Before the year was done The army that had won the east Had turned on everyone
The treaty signed the land away That Brusilov had bled to win And Galicia changed hands again As though they’d never been
Part of The Great War The Great War Chronicles All battles, in order