The Great War The First World War, on the Western Front
The Battle of the Somme, 1916
| Battle | the Somme |
|---|---|
| Date | 1 July to 18 November 1916 |
| War | The First World War, on the Western Front |
| Location | Both banks of the River Somme in Picardy, in today's Hauts-de-France, France |
| Belligerents | The British Empire and France vs the German Empire |
| Commanders | Sir Douglas Haig, with Sir Henry Rawlinson's Fourth Army, and Ferdinand Foch, with Émile Fayolle's French Sixth Army, vs Erich von Falkenhayn, replaced in August by Paul von Hindenburg, with Fritz von Below's Second Army |
| Strength | On 1 July, 13 British and 11 French divisions against about ten and a half German. By November some 50 British and 48 French divisions had fought there, against about 50 German |
| Outcome | No breakthrough. The Allies gained six or seven miles in four and a half months, and the offensive was closed down on 18 November |
| Allied losses | About 420,000 British Empire and 200,000 French casualties. On the first day alone the British suffered 57,470, of whom 19,240 were killed |
| German losses | Contested, and usually put between 450,000 and 500,000. The British official history's higher figure is no longer accepted |
The Account
In the summer of 1916 the British and French armies were going to break the German line in Picardy, along the chalk ridges north and south of the River Somme. The British part of the plan rested on the guns. For a week from the twenty-fourth of June they fired about a million and a half shells into the German positions. The idea was that nothing would be left alive in the German trenches and nothing left standing of the German wire, and that the infantry could then walk across and take possession.
Rain held the attack back two days. The first of July came up dry and clear and hot. At twenty past seven a mine went up under Hawthorn Ridge, and a cameraman filmed it. At twenty-eight minutes past, a much bigger one went up under the German line at La Boisselle and left a hole in the chalk that is still there. At half past seven the barrage lifted off the German front line, the officers blew their whistles, and all along the British front the infantry went up the ladders.
The guns had not done what was promised. A great many of the shells had been shrapnel, which does very little to wire or to men thirty feet down in a dugout, and a great many had not gone off at all. In the north the wire was largely whole. The German machine-gunners had sat out the week underground, and in the minutes between the barrage lifting and the British arriving they came up the stairs with their guns and set them on the parapet.
The men had been told to keep a steady pace and keep their lines. Some went across at a walk. Many had crept out into no man’s land before zero and lay there waiting, and rose at the whistle. A lot of them got no further than a few yards from where they started. Some battalions lost most of their men before they had cleared their own wire.
I was in no man’s land when they came. That morning it was full of them in every state: men walking, men lying flat, men caught on wire, men in shell holes who could not move, and men in long rows where a gun had found the line, lying as they had been standing.
By the end of the day the British army had lost fifty-seven thousand men killed, wounded or missing, nineteen thousand of them dead. It is still the worst day in its history. South of the river the French, who had more heavy guns and better ground, took nearly everything they had been asked to take, and almost no one in Britain remembers that they were there at all.
The wounded lay out between the lines for days. Some lived a week out there by eating the rations of the dead.
And then the battle went on. It went on through July and August, through the woods with names like High Wood and Delville Wood, through September, when the first tanks came forward, and into October, when the rain came and the chalk turned to a white mud that drowned men in shell holes. It was closed down on the eighteenth of November in sleet, six or seven miles beyond where it began.
More than a million men were killed or wounded on the Somme in those four and a half months, on both sides together. I will not pretend I could keep up with them. Every day there was another whistle somewhere, and another line going up a ladder, and I learned all of them.
Behind the Song
The Song
Listen onSpotifyApple MusicThe Great War Chronicles
Why follow?
Spotify no longer recommends music it identifies as made with AI, unless the listener follows the artist. Lady Death is performed by AI, so a follow is the only way new records will reach you there: in Release Radar, in your recommendations, and on release day. Playing a song helps. Following helps far more.
Why the Somme
The Somme is the battle the English-speaking world means when it says “the Great War.” It has the most famous first day of any battle in that war, and it went on for four and a half months after that day.
The difficulty with a song about it is scale. A million casualties is a number, and a number cannot be sung to. So this track does what the working note asks for and follows three men, one in each of three waves, and lets the chorus be the whistle that sends each of them.
The song, against the history
It opens on the chorus. There is no introduction and no first verse to settle into. The whistle has already blown. Every chorus is followed by three seconds of a real First World War trench whistle, laid in during production, and then the next man goes over.
“The whistle blows and they’re standing at the wall” is the moment itself: officers’ whistles, ladders against the trench wall, the men going up them. “The whistle blows and another thousand falls” is the arithmetic of 1 July, when the British army lost 57,470 men in a single day.
Verse 1 is the long death. The man goes up, crosses ground the shelling has torn up, and reaches the wire: “The wire catches him across the chest / His hands are pulling at the tangled mesh.” On the northern half of the front on 1 July the German wire had survived the bombardment largely intact, and men were caught on it in full view of the machine guns. “A bullet finds him and he falls without a sound” is the line the working note singles out. The bullet finds him, casually, as if it had been looking.
Verse 2 is the instant death, and the structure does the work. The man clears the parapet, “squints against the sun,” and is shot before he stands up. That detail is right for 1 July, a cloudless morning that Siegfried Sassoon, watching from the line, described as brilliant sunshine. Many men on the first day were hit on their own parapet or in their own wire. Verse 1 teaches the listener to expect a journey, and Verse 2 ends this one in four lines. The rest of the verse fills the space where he was: “The next man up the ladder doesn’t stop / He steps across the body at the top.”
Then she speaks for herself: “I stand beside the ladder and I wait / I touch each hand that passes through the gate.”
Verse 3 is the slow death, a man in a shell hole with his legs gone, calling for help as the line moves on without him. It is the most common death the Somme gave and the one written about least. Wounded men lay out in no man’s land for hours and days, some of them for a week. The crater “full of rain” belongs to the later Somme. The battle ran from July into November, and from October the rain turned the ground to mud and the shell holes into ponds.
There is no bridge and no outro. The song ends on the chorus, on “The whistle blows and they come to me again,” because the Somme did not end on 1 July. The silence after the last line is where the next wave goes up, and the one after that.
Lyrics
[Chorus] The whistle blows and they’re standing at the wall, The whistle blows and they answer when it calls, I’m waiting in the wire and the mud and the rain, The whistle blows and they come to me again, The whistle blows and I watch them climb the wall, The whistle blows and another thousand falls, I’m standing where the last wave met the mud, The whistle blows and they come to me again,
[Verse 1] His hands are shaking and he grips the rung, His feet hit mud before his prayer is done, The line moves forward and the air turns black, The man beside him drops and he doesn’t look back,
The shells have turned the field to broken ground, He jumps a crater where a man has drowned, The smoke is thick and he can barely see, He stumbles where the line ahead should be,
The wire catches him across the chest, His hands are pulling at the tangled mesh, The ground around him kicks with every round, A bullet finds him and he falls without a sound,
[Chorus] The whistle blows and they’re standing at the wall, The whistle blows and they answer when it calls, I’m waiting in the wire and the mud and the rain, The whistle blows and they come to me again, The whistle blows and I watch them climb the wall, The whistle blows and another thousand falls, I’m standing where the last wave met the mud, The whistle blows and they come to me again,
[Verse 2] Another man steps forward to the rung, He clears the top and squints against the sun, A bullet catches him before he stands, He falls back down with a photograph in his hands,
The next man up the ladder doesn’t stop, He steps across the body at the top, The trench keeps feeding men into the fight, The Somme grinds on and there’s no end in sight,
I stand beside the ladder and I wait, I touch each hand that passes through the gate, A thousand men yet every one the same, I learn them all and I forget no name,
[Chorus] The whistle blows and they’re standing at the wall, The whistle blows and they answer when it calls, I’m waiting in the wire and the mud and the rain, The whistle blows and they come to me again, The whistle blows and I watch them climb the wall, The whistle blows and another thousand falls, I’m standing where the last wave met the mud, The whistle blows and they come to me again,
[Verse 3] The third man makes it halfway through the mud, A shell lands close and fills his ears with blood, He drops into a crater full of rain, The mud is red before he feels the pain,
He looks down at the place his legs should be, There’s nothing there but blood below the knee, He calls for help but no one’s turning back, The line moved on and left him in the black,
The hours pass and the cold sets in his bones, His breathing slows as he’s dying all alone, I slide into the crater at his side, And I hold him in the mud until he dies,
[Chorus] The whistle blows and they’re standing at the wall, The whistle blows and they answer when it calls, I’m waiting in the wire and the mud and the rain, The whistle blows and they come to me again, The whistle blows and I watch them climb the wall, The whistle blows and another thousand falls, I’m standing where the last wave met the mud, The whistle blows and they come to me again,
Part of The Great War The Great War Chronicles All battles, in order